
How Rate the Loan Works: From Teller Window to Bank President
Rate the Loan is a banking game inside Rapunzl in which a student reads a borrower's credit file and then denies the loan, approves it at the borrower's rate, or sets a price of their own. Every choice lands in a loan book, and the book is graded on how well the student priced risk, not on how much money it made.
The game fits Personal Finance or Economics. A student starts as a Loan Clerk at a single teller window and works up through seven ranks to Bank President, with a bigger bank and new kinds of loans at each step.
A loan is a bet on whether someone repays, and the interest rate is the price of that bet. The game teaches students to read the odds, set the price and live with the result.
What does a student do at the loan desk?
Each quarter, loan applications arrive at the desk and the student makes one of three calls on each. Deny passes on the loan: the bank lends nothing, risks nothing and earns nothing. Approve funds the loan right away at the borrower's own rate, and the borrower always takes it, but that rate may not be right for the bank. Price lets the student set a rate after reading the file, which can earn more, though the borrower may or may not accept.
A fair-rate meter sits beside the pricing choice. How much help a student gets depends on the difficulty tier chosen at the start. The picker describes Support as showing the fair rate, a risk hint and the chance the borrower says yes; Core as showing a fair-rate band and leaving the risk reading to the student; and Stretch as no hints, with extra terms, bank-wide policy and faster quarters. In play, the estimated default risk on the credit file appears only on Support, and the chance-the-borrower-accepts readout appears on Support and Core but not Stretch. Changing tiers mid-career starts a new career at the new tier, so pick one before the first period.
At the end of each quarter, a debrief ties the decisions back to the concepts. That is the moment to stop the room. You can read the student-facing overview on the Rate the Loan page.
What is on a loan application?
Every application is a person with a need: a first car, a house, inventory for a shop, tuition. The credit file under the borrower's picture holds the signals the student reads. In the game these are the credit score, debt-to-income, loan-to-value, income stability and, on loans with collateral, the down payment. On Support, the file also shows an estimated default risk. The loan amount, term and the rate the borrower is asking for sit alongside them.
Borrower types describe a need, never a stereotype. The risk comes from the signals, so two borrowers who want the same loan can land far apart on price.
| Signal | What it measures | Which way it pushes the fair rate |
|---|---|---|
| Credit score | Track record of repaying | A lower score raises it |
| Debt-to-income | How much income already goes to debt payments | A higher ratio raises it |
| Income stability | How steady the paycheck or revenue is | Shakier income raises it |
| Loan-to-value | Loan size against the collateral behind it | A higher ratio raises it, because less is recovered if the loan fails |
How do credit score, income stability and debt-to-income move the fair rate?
Each signal changes the borrower's probability of default, and the fair rate is built on top of that probability. In the game, the fair rate is the rate that covers the bank's cost of funds, the expected loss on the loan, overhead and a fair profit. Expected loss is the chance of default multiplied by the share of the loan the bank would not recover.
Here is a hypothetical applicant, with every figure made up for illustration. The bank's cost of funds is 3.0%. The borrower has a 6% yearly chance of default, and a car loan like this would lose 45% of its balance if it failed, so expected loss is 6% x 45% = 2.7%. Add 1.5% for overhead, 1.0% for the capital the bank must hold behind the loan and 1.0% as a target profit, and the fair rate is 3.0 + 2.7 + 1.5 + 1.0 + 1.0 = 9.2%. Give the same illustration a weaker credit score and shakier income, and the default chance rises, expected loss rises with it and the fair rate climbs. Nothing else in the formula had to change.
That gives students a concrete answer to a question worth asking out loud: why does my rate differ from yours? Student loans are one of the segments students reach at Underwriter, so it is a good moment to compare the game's pricing with how student loan interest rates are set in practice and ask what differs.
Collateral works through the second half of expected loss. A larger down payment lowers loan-to-value, which cuts the amount lost when a collateralized loan fails. In the game, mortgages, auto loans and commercial real estate carry that collateral effect, while personal loans and cards do not.
Deny, approve or price: when does each one win?
Price wins when the file is workable and the student sets the rate near fair. Approve is a shortcut that borrows the borrower's ask, so it is only right when that ask happens to land close to fair. Deny belongs on files where no reasonable rate covers the risk.
Two traps sit on either side of fair. Price too low and the bank books a loan that loses money in expectation. Price too high and borrowers start walking away, and the strongest borrowers leave first because they have the most alternatives. That leaves a riskier pool behind, a pattern the game's glossary calls adverse selection. Pricing far above fair also makes the loan harder to afford, which nudges its real default risk up, so gouging hurts the bank as well as the borrower.
Denying is not a free pass either. Turning away every file earns nothing on pricing, because no pricing skill was shown, and a book with no loans in it has nothing to diversify.
What are the seven chapters and ranks?
The campaign has seven chapters, and each one pairs a rank with a stretch of the business cycle and a new loan type. Promotion comes from objectives such as pricing a set number of loans within tolerance of fair, lending across several loan types, and staying solvent through the downturn.
| Rank | Chapter | New loans at this rank |
|---|---|---|
| Loan Clerk | The Teller Window | Personal and auto |
| Loan Officer | The Loan Desk | Credit cards |
| Underwriter | The Mortgage Boom | Mortgages and student loans |
| Credit Risk Manager | The Downturn | Small-business lending and loan-loss reserves |
| Branch Manager | Main Street | Commercial real estate and a concentration-limit policy |
| Chief Lending Officer | The Big Book | Corporate credit lines and a bank-wide underwriting-standard dial |
| Bank President | Running the Bank | The whole balance sheet |
The bank grows in four stages as the student climbs, from a single teller window to a neighborhood branch, an established bank and a headquarters. The fourth chapter is the one to watch. In The Downturn, the fair rate jumps across the book, and the game expects students to reprice for the new risk instead of freezing or dumping loans. If you teach the Fed side of this, how Run The Fed works covers the game from the central bank's chair.
How is the loan book scored, and why does fair lending count?
The Underwriter Score grades the thinking behind the book. It combines five parts: pricing accuracy, risk-adjusted return (RAROC), soundness, diversification and fair lending. Soundness reflects how many loans were charged off and whether the bank stayed solvent. The design goal is simple: a reckless, gouging book that blows up in a downturn scores below a calm, accurately priced, diversified one.
Fair lending carries weight because the game charges for both kinds of unfairness. Offering a rate far above fair counts against the student, and so does denying a borrower whose file shows a very low chance of default. The score checks both against the borrower's hidden default risk.
The score is separate from the bank's rating. The rating runs from AAA to D and reflects five factors in the bank's own balance sheet: capital, asset quality, earnings, diversification and liquidity. A better rating lowers the bank's cost of funds, so careful lending makes the next loan cheaper to fund. If losses outrun capital, or new loans drain cash to zero, the bank fails and the game says so plainly.
Which mistakes does the game flag?
The debrief watches for six recurring errors and coaches on each one when it happens:
- Denying a creditworthy borrower, which is a fair-lending miss and a wasted good loan.
- Pricing below breakeven, so the rate does not cover funding plus expected loss.
- Gouging a borrower with a rate well above fair.
- Lending into a sector at the moment a shock is hitting it.
- Piling into one loan type until it dominates the book.
- Chasing the boom by lending at the top of the cycle on thin collateral.
Growing the book faster than cash and capital can support ends the run outright. The game's lesson is that a smaller book that survives beats a big one that fails.
Debrief questions to ask after a session
Ask these before anyone looks at a final score, and ask for evidence from the student's own decisions.
- Pick one loan you priced above the borrower's ask. What in the file justified the higher rate?
- Which signal moved your fair rate the most on a single borrower, and how do you know?
- Find a denial you would reverse. What price would have made the loan work?
- Which loan type grew fastest in your book? What would a downturn in that type have done to you?
If you already run a classroom economy, the loan side of the game gives your class bank something to compare against: ask whether the class loan rate you set would survive the fair-rate test. For the other games in the set, see our overview of economics mini-games for high school.
Frequently Asked
Questions
Plan on several class periods across the seven chapters. You can run it in class-period chunks or assign chapters between sessions.
Personal Finance or Economics. In Personal Finance it supports credit and borrowing units from the lender's side, and in Economics it supports banks, interest rates and the business cycle.
No. The Underwriter Score rewards pricing accuracy, risk-adjusted return, soundness, diversification and fair lending, so a calm, honest book can outscore a flashy one that fails in a downturn.
The student earns nothing on pricing, because no loan was priced, and an empty book has nothing to diversify. Denial is a real tool, but only on files where no reasonable rate covers the risk.
Switching tiers starts a new career at the new difficulty, so rank, cleared chapters and the bank all reset. Choose Support, Core or Stretch before the first session.
If you want to see the curriculum modules, the simulator and the educator tools next to the game, Request a demo and a Rapunzl team member will set it up. If you are a parent, the parents page shows what Rapunzl offers families.
By Maria Rodriguez, Curriculum Designer at Rapunzl.
Get the free Loans & Credit teaching pack
Slide deck + 2 ready-to-teach worksheets — Understanding Credit Scores and Reading a Credit Card Statement — plus both answer keys. Free.











